What is a decoy vault, and does it work?
A decoy vault lets one app open two different ways: one secret shows your real files, another shows a harmless set. Here is how it works, when it helps, and where it stops helping.
The idea in one paragraph
A normal vault app has one lock and one set of contents. A decoy vault adds a second set. You choose two secrets. One opens your real vault. The other opens a different vault that you have filled with things you do not mind showing. From the outside, both look like “the vault”.
People also call this a fake vault or a second-password vault.
Why anyone would want one
A lock protects you from people who cannot make you open it. Some people can.
“What’s in that app? Show me.” It might be a partner, a parent, a flatmate, a colleague who saw the icon. Refusing is an answer in itself. A decoy gives you another choice: open the app, show something dull, and let the moment pass.
That is the whole purpose. A decoy does not make the lock stronger. It gives you a way out of a conversation.
How it works
There are two very different ways to build one, and they look the same on screen.
The weak way: one store, two views. The app keeps all files together and only decides which ones to show, based on the code you typed. The real files are still there, protected by nothing more than a setting. A person with a file tool, or a flaw in the app, can reach them.
The strong way: separate vaults, separate keys. Each vault is encrypted with a key made from its own secret. The decoy secret cannot open the real vault, because it produces a different key.
The strong way only exists in apps where your secret is the encryption key in the first place. Our guide to pattern locks explains that difference.
A good decoy also has these properties:
- The lock screen is identical. There is no “enter decoy code” button and no different colour.
- Nothing inside the decoy points to the other vault. No counter saying “vault 2 of 2”, no switch in settings.
- It deletes nothing, unless you clearly asked for that. Some apps wipe the real vault when a special code is typed. That can be the right tool for a few people, but for most it is a way to lose files by mistake.
When a decoy helps
| Situation | Does a decoy help? |
|---|---|
| Someone curious asks to see what is in the app | Yes |
| Someone who knows your iPhone passcode opens the app when you are not there | The lock helps here, not the decoy |
| A thief takes your phone | The encryption helps here, not the decoy |
| Someone who knows the app has a decoy feature insists on “the other one” | Not much |
| Someone watched you enter your real secret | No |
| An expert examines the phone with special tools | A decoy is not built for this |
| An official with legal power orders you to unlock | This is a legal question. See below |
The first row is the common one, and that is where a decoy earns its place.
The honest limits
It cannot hide that the feature exists. If an app’s store page says “decoy vault”, anyone can read that. A person who already suspects you, and knows the app, can say: “Now show me the other one.” A decoy works on people who do not know what to look for. It does not work on people who do.
The app itself is visible. A vault app on your Home Screen is a statement. iOS lets you hide a downloaded app, but Apple says a hidden app can still be visible in other places on the iPhone, such as the Hidden Apps list in Settings.
An empty decoy convinces nobody. A vault with nothing in it, or with three photos added the day you installed it, looks like what it is. Put ordinary private things in it: copies of documents, family photos, a few notes. Open it now and then.
Clues can sit outside the app. If the real photos are still in your camera roll or in Recently Deleted, the decoy is beside the point.
It does not replace a strong secret. If the real pattern or password is easy to guess or was seen, the decoy changes nothing.
It is built for social pressure. A consumer app’s decoy is designed for a person looking at your screen. It cannot help if that person already knows there is more.
The law differs by country
A decoy vault is a privacy tool for everyday life. Rules on unlocking a device differ by country, and this guide is not legal advice.
How to set one up well
- Make the decoy secret the easier one. If someone watches you, it is the one you can afford to have seen.
- Make the two secrets clearly different, so you do not open the wrong vault by accident.
- Fill the decoy with believable, harmless things.
- Clean up the originals. Delete the real photos from Photos and empty Recently Deleted. See every way to hide photos on iPhone.
- Practise once. Open the decoy as if someone had asked you to.
How Vahty does it
We make Vahty, a vault app for iPhone. It is in final testing and not on the App Store yet.
- Vahty can hold several vaults. The main pattern opens every vault. Any vault can also get its own pattern, and drawing that pattern on the lock screen opens only that vault.
- That vault is the decoy. Nothing on screen says other vaults exist, and the lock screen looks identical.
- The pattern is the encryption key, not a screen in front of the files.
- The decoy deletes nothing.
- Wrong guesses cost time. After 5 wrong patterns the waits are 30 seconds, 1 minute, 5 minutes, 30 minutes, then 1 hour per try.
The limits above apply to Vahty too. Our website says Vahty has a decoy vault, so a person who knows the app may ask for a second pattern. And Vahty has not yet had an independent security audit. One is planned. What we can and cannot protect is set out on the security page, and there is a side-by-side comparison with another pattern vault.
In short
- A decoy vault is a second vault opened by a second secret.
- It helps with social pressure: “show me what is in there”.
- It works best when each vault has its own encryption key and the lock screen gives nothing away.
- It does not help against someone who knows to ask for the other vault, or who saw your real secret.
- Rules on unlocking devices differ by country. This guide is not legal advice.
Questions
What is a decoy vault?
A decoy vault is a second vault inside the same app, opened by a different password, PIN or pattern. If you are pressed to open the app, you enter the decoy secret and the app shows only the harmless contents.
Can someone tell that a vault app has a decoy?
A well-made app shows nothing on screen that gives it away. But anyone can read that the app offers a decoy feature, so a person who knows the app may suspect there is a second vault and ask for it.
Does a decoy vault delete my real files?
It depends on the app. Some designs wipe the real vault when a special code is entered. Others, including Vahty, delete nothing: the decoy opens a different vault. Check before you rely on it.
Is it legal to use a decoy vault?
Rules differ by country. This guide is not legal advice.